top of page

Understanding Your Cholesterol: Is It Carbs, Fat, Stress, or Something Else?

4 days ago
14 min read

Why high cholesterol isn't always as simple as eating too much fat

When most people hear the words high cholesterol, they immediately think about butter, bacon, cheese, steak and other fatty foods. For decades, we've been told that eating too much fat leads to high cholesterol, which in turn increases our risk of heart disease.

But cholesterol metabolism is much more complicated than that.





Did you know that eating too many refined carbohydrates can significantly change your cholesterol levels? Or that chronic stress and poor sleep can affect the way your body processes blood sugar and fat?

Even your liver, thyroid, hormones, genetics, and gallbladder can play a role.

Cholesterol itself isn't the enemy. In fact, it's absolutely essential for life! Our bodies use cholesterol to build cell membranes, manufacture hormones, produce vitamin D, and create bile acids that help us digest fats.

The problem arises when certain cholesterol-carrying particles become too abundant in our bloodstream, increasing the risk of plaque accumulating in our arteries.

Let's explore what your cholesterol panel is actually telling us, why those numbers might be elevated, and what you can do to improve your cardiovascular and metabolic health.

First, What Are We Actually Measuring?

A standard cholesterol panel typically includes four main measurements:

Total Cholesterol: The overall amount of cholesterol circulating in your blood. This number alone doesn't tell us very much about your cardiovascular risk.

LDL Cholesterol (LDL-C): Commonly called "bad cholesterol," LDL transports cholesterol throughout the bloodstream. When LDL particles become too abundant, they can contribute to plaque formation in our arteries.

HDL Cholesterol (HDL-C): Often called "good cholesterol," HDL participates in transporting cholesterol from tissues back toward the liver. Higher HDL is often associated with better metabolic health, but high HDL doesn't automatically protect someone from heart disease.

Triglycerides: These are fats circulating in your blood that your body uses and stores for energy. Elevated triglycerides are frequently associated with insulin resistance, excessive refined carbohydrate intake, alcohol consumption, and metabolic dysfunction.

There are also two additional blood markers I like to consider when evaluating cardiovascular health.

Apolipoprotein B (ApoB): This helps us estimate the number of potentially artery-clogging lipoprotein particles circulating in the blood. While LDL cholesterol measures how much cholesterol is being carried inside LDL particles, ApoB tells us approximately how many atherogenic particles are present. This can provide a clearer picture of cardiovascular risk, particularly when triglycerides are elevated or insulin resistance is present.

Lipoprotein(a), or Lp(a): Sometimes called "lipoprotein little a," this is a largely genetically determined cardiovascular risk factor. Unlike many other cholesterol markers, Lp(a) is not significantly influenced by ordinary dietary changes. Current Canadian guidelines recommend measuring it at least once during adulthood.

These additional markers can help us understand cardiovascular risk beyond what a standard cholesterol panel reveals.

How Eating Too Many Carbohydrates Affects Cholesterol

Here's something that surprises many patients: eating excessive amounts of refined carbohydrates can actually increase the amount of fat circulating in your blood.

When we consume carbohydrates, our digestive system breaks many of them down into glucose, which enters our bloodstream.

Our pancreas releases insulin to help move that glucose into our cells, where it can be used for energy or stored for later.

But what happens when we're consistently consuming more energy than our bodies need, particularly from refined carbohydrates and added sugars?

Our liver can convert some of that excess carbohydrate into fat through a process called de novo lipogenesis.

The liver then packages these newly manufactured fats into particles called very-low-density lipoproteins (VLDL), which transport triglycerides throughout the bloodstream.

Over time, particularly when insulin resistance develops, this can contribute to elevated triglycerides, reduced HDL cholesterol, and changes in the number and composition of LDL particles.

Why Does Insulin Resistance Matter?

Insulin resistance develops when our cells become less responsive to insulin's signals.

Our pancreas often compensates by producing more insulin to maintain normal blood sugar levels.

Meanwhile, insulin-resistant fat tissue releases more fatty acids into circulation, providing the liver with additional material for triglyceride production.

This can create a cycle of increased liver fat, elevated triglycerides, altered cholesterol transport, and worsening metabolic health.

It's one reason I pay close attention to blood sugar regulation when patients come in with cholesterol concerns.

And importantly, someone can have insulin resistance for years before their fasting blood sugar becomes significantly elevated.

Does this mean carbohydrates are bad?

Absolutely not!

There is an enormous difference between eating vegetables, legumes, whole grains, and high-fibre fruits versus regularly consuming sugary beverages, pastries, and heavily refined carbohydrates.

Fibre slows carbohydrate absorption, supports beneficial gut bacteria, improves satiety, and can help regulate both blood sugar and cholesterol.

The goal isn't necessarily to eliminate carbohydrates. It's to choose the right carbohydrates, in amounts that work for your individual metabolism.

What About Eating Too Much Fat?

Dietary fat has been blamed for high cholesterol for decades, but not all fats behave the same way in our bodies.

One of the most important distinctions is between saturated and unsaturated fats.

Saturated fats, found in foods such as butter, cream, coconut oil, fatty meats, and many cheeses, can increase LDL cholesterol in many individuals.

One reason is that saturated fat can reduce the liver's ability to remove LDL particles from the bloodstream.

When LDL particles remain in circulation longer, LDL cholesterol and ApoB can rise.

However, genetics and individual metabolism influence how strongly someone responds to saturated fat.

Unsaturated fats, found in olive oil, avocados, nuts, seeds, and fatty fish, generally have a more favourable effect on cholesterol levels, particularly when they replace saturated fats.

Interestingly, eating more fat doesn't automatically mean higher triglycerides. In fact, someone following a lower-carbohydrate diet may have very low triglycerides despite consuming substantial amounts of dietary fat.

What About Keto and Low-Carb Diets?

Low-carbohydrate and ketogenic diets can produce some impressive metabolic improvements in certain people.

Triglycerides often decrease, HDL cholesterol may increase, and blood sugar regulation can improve.

But there's a catch.

Some individuals experience significant increases in LDL cholesterol and ApoB, particularly when their diet is high in saturated fat.

This means it's possible to have excellent triglycerides, high HDL, and very good blood sugar control while still having elevated cardiovascular risk from excessive numbers of LDL particles.

This is why I believe it's important to evaluate the entire picture rather than assuming that a diet is working perfectly simply because some markers have improved.

What Does Your Liver Have to Do With Cholesterol?

Quite a lot!

Your liver is essentially the control centre for cholesterol metabolism.

It manufactures cholesterol, packages triglycerides into lipoproteins, removes circulating LDL particles, and converts cholesterol into bile acids.

In fact, a substantial amount of the cholesterol in our bodies is manufactured internally rather than coming directly from the food we eat.

When the liver is functioning well, it carefully regulates cholesterol production, transport, and removal.

But when metabolic dysfunction develops, particularly insulin resistance or fatty liver disease, these processes can become disrupted.

Fat can begin accumulating within liver cells, and the liver may release more triglyceride-rich particles into circulation.

This is one reason elevated triglycerides and cholesterol abnormalities can sometimes provide clues about underlying fatty liver disease, now commonly called metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD).

Of course, not every person with abnormal cholesterol has a liver problem, and liver enzymes can be normal even when fatty liver is present.

But it's worth remembering that cholesterol doesn't exist in isolation.

It's intimately connected to our liver, blood sugar regulation, hormones, and overall metabolic health.

What Else Can Influence Your Cholesterol?

Although nutrition plays an important role in cholesterol metabolism, there are several other factors that can influence your results.

Stress and Cortisol

This is one of the connections I find particularly interesting.

When we're under stress, our bodies activate the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, which stimulates the release of cortisol.

Cortisol is one of our primary stress hormones, and it's absolutely essential for survival.

One of its jobs is to help ensure that enough glucose is available in our bloodstream when we need energy.

It does this partly by signalling the liver to produce and release more glucose.

This is incredibly useful when we're responding to an immediate threat. But when stress becomes chronic, prolonged activation of our stress-response systems may contribute to problems with blood sugar regulation.

Higher cortisol exposure can reduce insulin sensitivity, particularly when combined with inadequate sleep, inactivity, and other metabolic risk factors.

As insulin resistance develops, our bodies may have more difficulty regulating circulating glucose and fatty acids.

And as we've already discussed, insulin resistance can contribute to increased triglyceride production, lower HDL cholesterol, and elevated numbers of atherogenic lipoprotein particles.

In other words, chronic stress can indirectly influence your cholesterol through its effects on blood sugar, insulin sensitivity, sleep, and metabolic health.

Of course, not everyone experiencing chronic stress has persistently elevated cortisol, and the relationship is more complicated than simply "stress raises cholesterol."

But stress management absolutely deserves a place in conversations about cardiovascular health.

Thyroid Function

Thyroid hormones help regulate how efficiently our bodies process and remove cholesterol.

When thyroid hormone levels are low, LDL particles may remain in circulation longer, contributing to elevated LDL cholesterol.

This is why thyroid function is an important consideration when investigating unexplained cholesterol elevations.

Genetics

Some people inherit genetic variations that significantly affect how their bodies manufacture, transport, or remove cholesterol.

Familial hypercholesterolemia, for example, can cause very high LDL cholesterol from a young age, regardless of how carefully someone eats.

This is also why family history matters. A history of heart attacks or strokes at relatively young ages may point toward inherited cardiovascular risk.

Menopause and Hormonal Changes

Estrogen influences cholesterol metabolism, insulin sensitivity, and fat distribution.

As estrogen levels decline during menopause, LDL cholesterol may increase, while changes in body composition can contribute to worsening insulin sensitivity.

This is one reason cardiovascular risk can change substantially during the menopausal transition, even when a woman's eating habits haven't changed.

Poor Sleep

Insufficient or disrupted sleep can negatively affect insulin sensitivity, appetite regulation, blood pressure, and stress hormones.

Sleep apnea is also associated with metabolic dysfunction and increased cardiovascular risk.

Consistently poor sleep can make it harder to maintain healthy blood sugar and lipid levels.

Physical Inactivity

Regular movement helps our muscles use glucose more efficiently and improves insulin sensitivity.

Without adequate physical activity, our bodies may become less efficient at regulating blood sugar and triglycerides.

Alcohol, Medications, and Other Medical Conditions

Alcohol, particularly in larger amounts, can increase triglycerides.

Certain medications, including corticosteroids and some blood pressure or hormonal medications, may also influence cholesterol metabolism.

Kidney disease and other medical conditions can affect lipid levels as well.

All of these factors reinforce why cholesterol should be assessed in the context of someone's overall health.

What Can You Do to Improve Your Cholesterol?

The good news is that there are many practical ways to support healthier cholesterol levels and reduce cardiovascular risk.

And you don't necessarily need to overhaul your entire life overnight!

The most effective strategy depends on whether we're primarily trying to improve triglycerides, lower LDL cholesterol and ApoB, address insulin resistance, or manage several factors at once.

Here are some of the approaches I most commonly consider.

1. Reduce Refined Carbohydrates and Added Sugars

If triglycerides are elevated or insulin resistance is suspected, this can be a particularly valuable place to start.

Focus on reducing foods and beverages that deliver large amounts of sugar or rapidly absorbed carbohydrates without much fibre.

Examples include sugary drinks, sweetened coffees, candy, pastries, and heavily refined snack foods.

Instead, build meals around vegetables, fibre-rich carbohydrates, protein, and healthy fats.

Consider including protein and fibre with carbohydrate-containing meals to help moderate blood sugar responses.

A useful starting point is simply replacing sweetened beverages with water, sparkling water, or unsweetened tea.

This doesn't mean you need to eliminate fruit, potatoes, or every carbohydrate you enjoy. The goal is improved metabolic regulation, not unnecessary restriction.

2. Be Mindful of Saturated Fat

If LDL cholesterol or ApoB is elevated, take a closer look at how much saturated fat you're eating.

You don't necessarily need to avoid every food containing saturated fat, but regularly consuming large amounts of butter, cream, coconut oil, cheese, and fatty meats can make it harder to lower LDL cholesterol.

Try substituting olive oil for some of the butter you use in cooking, choosing fish more frequently, or including nuts and avocado as sources of fat.

The important part is replacing saturated fats with unsaturated fats rather than simply adding or subtracting fat in your diet.

And remember, low-carb doesn't have to mean high saturated fat!

3. Increase Soluble Fibre

This is one of my favourite nutritional strategies for supporting healthy cholesterol levels.

Soluble fibre forms a gel-like substance in the digestive tract and can help lower LDL cholesterol by influencing bile acid and cholesterol metabolism.

Some excellent sources include:

  • Oats and barley

  • Beans, lentils, and chickpeas

  • Ground flaxseed and chia seeds

  • Apples, citrus fruits, and other fibre-rich produce

  • Psyllium husk

Psyllium is particularly interesting because studies have shown that regular consumption can modestly reduce LDL cholesterol.

For adults, a general fibre goal is around 25–38 grams daily, depending on age, sex, and individual needs.

If your current diet is low in fibre, increase gradually and drink enough water to minimize bloating and digestive discomfort.

4. Move Your Body Every Day

Exercise is one of the most effective ways to improve insulin sensitivity and metabolic health.

When our muscles contract, they can take up glucose from the bloodstream through pathways that don't rely entirely on insulin.

This means physical activity helps regulate blood sugar both during exercise and afterward.

Regular movement can also lower triglycerides, improve blood pressure, and support cardiovascular health.

Aim for approximately 150 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity each week, along with strength training at least twice weekly.

Walking, cycling, swimming, dancing, and hiking are all excellent options.

One particularly simple strategy is taking a 10–15 minute walk after meals.

This can help reduce post-meal blood sugar elevations and is an easy habit to incorporate into daily life.

And don't underestimate resistance training! Building and maintaining muscle helps support glucose metabolism as we age.

5. Prioritize Your Sleep

Sleep is often overlooked when we're discussing cholesterol.

But chronically inadequate sleep can affect insulin sensitivity, hunger hormones, cortisol regulation, and cardiovascular health.

Aim for approximately 7–9 hours of sleep per night.

Try maintaining consistent sleep and wake times, reducing evening alcohol intake, getting natural light in the morning, and creating a cool, dark sleeping environment.

If you're experiencing significant snoring, waking up gasping, or persistent daytime fatigue, consider an assessment for sleep apnea.

Improving sleep may not dramatically reduce LDL cholesterol on its own, but it can make a meaningful difference to overall metabolic health.

6. Take Stress Management Seriously

If chronic stress can contribute to insulin resistance and metabolic dysfunction, then managing stress should be part of our cardiovascular health strategy.

That doesn't mean you need to eliminate every stressful situation from your life. That's simply not realistic.

Instead, focus on creating opportunities for your nervous system to recover.

Some useful strategies include:

  • Spending time outdoors

  • Gentle exercise and walking

  • Meditation or mindfulness practices

  • Yoga and breathing exercises

  • Social connection

  • Making time for enjoyable hobbies

  • Setting boundaries around work and responsibilities

Even a few minutes of intentional relaxation each day can be a valuable starting point.

Stress reduction isn't a replacement for treating elevated LDL or ApoB, but it's an important component of supporting long-term metabolic and cardiovascular health.

7. Support a Healthy Body Composition

Excess visceral fat, the fat that accumulates around our abdominal organs, is particularly associated with insulin resistance and metabolic dysfunction.

When appropriate, even modest weight loss can improve triglycerides, insulin sensitivity, and liver fat.

However, weight isn't the whole story.

Someone can have a relatively normal body weight and still experience insulin resistance or elevated cholesterol.

And someone living in a larger body may still make substantial improvements in metabolic health through exercise and nutritional changes, even without major weight loss.

The goal is to improve metabolic function, not simply chase a number on the scale.

8. Include Foods That Naturally Support Cholesterol Metabolism

Certain foods have particularly interesting effects on cholesterol and cardiovascular health.

Fatty fish: Salmon, sardines, trout, and mackerel provide omega-3 fatty acids that support cardiovascular health. Higher-dose omega-3 supplementation can lower triglycerides, although its effects on LDL cholesterol and cardiovascular outcomes depend on the formulation and dose.

Nuts: Almonds, walnuts, and pistachios provide unsaturated fats, fibre, and plant compounds that can support healthy cholesterol levels.

Olive oil: Extra-virgin olive oil is rich in monounsaturated fats and polyphenols. It's an excellent replacement for butter and other saturated-fat-rich cooking fats.

Legumes: Beans, chickpeas, and lentils provide soluble fibre, plant protein, and carbohydrates that are generally digested more slowly.

Oats and barley: These contain beta-glucan, a soluble fibre with well-established LDL-lowering benefits.

Vegetables and fruit: These provide fibre, potassium, antioxidants, and a variety of plant compounds that support cardiovascular health.

Rather than searching for one miracle food, think about the overall pattern of your diet.

A Mediterranean-style eating pattern emphasizing vegetables, legumes, fish, olive oil, nuts, fruit, and fibre-rich grains has substantial evidence supporting cardiovascular health.

9. Consider Targeted Supplements When Appropriate

There are a few supplements worth discussing when it comes to cholesterol management, although their benefits and safety profiles vary considerably.

Psyllium fibre: One of the better-supported options for modest LDL cholesterol reduction. It works in part by influencing bile acid recycling and can also support bowel regularity.

Plant sterols and stanols: These compounds reduce intestinal cholesterol absorption and can help lower LDL cholesterol when consumed in sufficient amounts. They are not a substitute for cardiovascular risk assessment or necessary medication.

Omega-3 fatty acids: EPA and DHA can lower triglycerides, particularly at therapeutic doses. However, over-the-counter fish oil supplements should not be assumed to provide the same cardiovascular benefits as specific prescription omega-3 formulations. High-dose products also require consideration of side effects and medication interactions.

Berberine: Some studies suggest possible improvements in blood sugar regulation and lipid markers, but the research is less consistent than it is for established lipid-lowering therapies. Berberine also has potential medication interactions and isn't appropriate for everyone.

Bergamot extract: Small studies have reported improvements in certain cholesterol markers, but the evidence remains preliminary, and standardized dosing and long-term cardiovascular benefits have not been established.

I always recommend choosing supplements based on the individual's needs rather than taking a collection of products marketed for "heart health."

Natural products can have side effects, interact with medications, and vary considerably in quality.

And importantly, supplements should not replace proven cholesterol-lowering medications when someone has significant cardiovascular risk.

10. Investigate Underlying Causes

Sometimes, despite making meaningful dietary and lifestyle changes, cholesterol remains elevated.

This is when it's particularly important to look deeper.

Could thyroid function be contributing?

Is insulin resistance present?

Are hormonal changes or menopause influencing metabolism?

Is there a strong family history of high cholesterol or early cardiovascular disease?

Are medications or kidney conditions playing a role?

And what do ApoB and Lp(a) tell us about cardiovascular risk?

Understanding these factors allows treatment to become much more individualized.

Which Blood Tests Are Worth Considering?

If cholesterol levels are elevated, I often like to look beyond the standard lipid panel.

Depending on the individual, useful investigations may include:

  • Standard cholesterol panel: Total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, triglycerides, and non-HDL cholesterol.

  • ApoB: To better understand the number of potentially atherogenic lipoprotein particles.

  • Lp(a): To evaluate inherited cardiovascular risk.

  • Hemoglobin A1c and fasting glucose: To assess blood sugar regulation.

  • Additional metabolic investigations: Thyroid function, liver enzymes, kidney function, and occasionally fasting insulin, depending on the clinical picture.

Fasting insulin may provide additional information in selected cases, but it isn't a standardized standalone test for diagnosing insulin resistance.

The goal isn't necessarily to test everything. It's to identify what will meaningfully improve our understanding of your health.

So, Is High Cholesterol Always Bad?

This is a question I hear frequently.

Cholesterol is essential for life. We need it for healthy cells, hormones, vitamin D production, and digestion.

The concern isn't the presence of cholesterol itself.

It's the amount of exposure our arteries have to potentially atherogenic lipoprotein particles over time.

Elevated LDL cholesterol and ApoB contribute to the development of atherosclerosis, particularly when combined with other risk factors such as high blood pressure, smoking, diabetes, and genetic susceptibility.

At the same time, cholesterol results can provide useful clues about other aspects of metabolic health.

Elevated triglycerides may encourage us to investigate insulin resistance. Changes around menopause may prompt a discussion about hormonal and metabolic changes. Unexpectedly high LDL cholesterol may lead us to investigate thyroid function, genetics, or dietary fat intake.

Understanding these connections is important because we're treating a person, not just a number.

The Bottom Line

Your cholesterol panel is about much more than how much fat you eat.

Refined carbohydrates can influence triglyceride production. Saturated fats can increase LDL cholesterol. Insulin resistance can disrupt how your body processes both sugar and fat.

Chronic stress, inadequate sleep, hormonal changes, thyroid dysfunction, genetics, and liver health can all contribute.


Even bile acid metabolism and gallbladder function have a relationship with how cholesterol moves through the body.

The good news is that many of these factors can be improved through thoughtful nutrition, regular physical activity, better sleep, stress management, and appropriate medical treatment.

The most important question isn't simply, "Is my cholesterol high?"

It's also, "Why is it high, and what can we do to improve my long-term health?"


At our naturopathic clinic in Lloydminster, we take a comprehensive approach to cholesterol and metabolic health. We look beyond individual laboratory numbers to better understand nutrition, lifestyle, metabolic function, and cardiovascular risk.

If you've been told your cholesterol is high, or you've made dietary changes without seeing the results you expected, a more individualized assessment may help you understand what comes next.


This article is intended for educational purposes only and does not replace individualized medical advice. Elevated cholesterol and other cardiovascular risk factors should be evaluated by an appropriately qualified healthcare professional. Do not discontinue prescribed cholesterol-lowering medications without consulting your healthcare provider.

 
 
 

Comments


Become an insider

Join our email list to get monthly tips from Kathryn King on ways to improve your health and live your best life.

By signing up, you agree to receive our monthly newsletter along with occasional updates about events, resources, and offerings from Kathryn King ND. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Submitted! We'll be in touch soon!

Screenshot 2023-02-15 at 9.49.44 AM.png

Kathryn King Naturopathic Doctor

3907 51 Avenue, Lloydminster AB

(306) 830-8982

info@kathrynkingnd.com

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
Navigation

The content provided on this website is intended for informational purposes only. We recommend all online visitors consult a healthcare professional before implementing any practices or supplements mentioned on this site, especially those with known health concerns, pregnant women, and individuals taking any medication or supplements. Kathryn King does not take responsibility for any health consequences or complications resulting from the information presented in the informational content on this website.

​

 © 2025 Kathryn King

bottom of page